Inventing Traditions by Eric Hobsbawm was an extremely interesting article and gave me a lot to think about in light of the other readings. Cho Hae Joang’s article on Sopyonje stated that “…the desire to find tradition and, within changed circumstances, revive it.” (138). This made me think, can a tradition that was “lost” be found and revived in the customary sense or does it become an invented tradition?
It’s important to define invented tradition, which Hobsbawm says is something which invokes or represents the past but is presented in a novel or new situation. A custom would be more of a historical ritual without the change in context. Does this mean that reviving p’ansori in a new and globalized culture makes it an invented tradition?
Also intriguing is the desire to revive a dead or dying custom at all. Like the step son in Sopyonje, it can seem pointless to perform an art which there is no longer a demand for. The art may have changed or disappeared completely, but there is no reason to continue a medium which essentially doesn’t exist anymore.
I think that the almost-debate going on here about nationalism and globalism can sort of be understood through the idea of invented tradition. As globalism takes hold, a nation and culture changes. This in turn can inspire a revival for more traditional culture, inventing traditions if you will. People begin practicing their old traditions in a new environment and perhaps in a modified way (for example, using modern amplification techniques when performing p’ansori) and invent a tradition. You can celebrate your national culture and identity through this created ceremony. It’s sort of like the hybridization that we read about a few classes ago. I don’t think nationalism and globalism have to be at odds.
But this does raise another question, if it is true that when an environment changes and a new tradition is revived or invented which invokes or represents the past, can we really hang on to any of our customs in their true forms?
Any thoughts?
1 comment:
I understand now that invented tradition can act as the "grey area" I was looking for between the two extremes... But I also ask the same question ("Can we really hang onto any of our customs in their true form")--especially if you wonder whether these INVENTED traditions can "substitute" true traditions at all... which then makes me wonder again maybe, after everything, globalism and nationalism are STILL at odds...??
Post a Comment